Star Tavern

Bangkok Baseball a month ago

This is a very tasty bar pizza. It could stand to be a bit more crispy on the undercarriage, but the taste of the pizza is excellent.

Ashok Kumar 4 months ago

Star Tavern in Orange has been a family favorite for decades. Their legendary thin‑crust pizza is perhaps the best in all of New Jersey — crisp, flavorful, and unforgettable. Every dish shines, from the pastas to the cavatelli with broccoli to the perfectly fried calamari. The service is always friendly, the bar is well stocked, and the atmosphere feels like home. A timeless Jersey classic that never disappoints.

Renato 5 months ago

I visited the Star Tavern on a Friday afternoon for a late lunch and enjoyed the food and service. My wife and I shared a garlic bread with mozzarella and a pizza (half 3 cheese/half white spinach) and even though the pizza is very thin it was more than enough food for us so keep that in mind if you go with multiple people and each one decides to order a pizza. Pizza was tasty, I’d rate it a 8.5/10, I just wish it had a little more cheese. Garlic bread was also pretty good. I had 2 Coors light draft ($5.50) and my wife had a ginger ale ($3.00 and refill was free). They should offer some happy hour specials during weekdays. Service was good and waitresses were friendly. There are some tables and booths in addition to bar stools. There’s a small parking lot so during peak hours you might need to find street parking.

Miss Brightandwell 7 months ago

Best pizza I’ve ever had hands down! New Jersey has a lot of good pizza but this one takes the cake. The flavor really comes out at this place. You can tell they take pride in making good pizza.

Craig Rudzenski 10 months ago

Took a ride from South Jersey for a pizza adventure. This was our 2nd time here. The first time, we went on a Friday Night in Lent and holy smokes.... . Today, we just grabbed two seats at the bar. Arrived about 1pm on a Saturday afternoon. It didn't look like any tables were available, and we weren't sure if friends were going to join us. . There were only two guys at the bar when we arrived. When we left around 2:30/3pm, the bar was about 90% full. . We went with an extra cheese pie and a pepperoni pie. Both were delicious. Our friend told us to ask for it well done, but we totally forgot (and WISH we rememberd). The only crispy thing on the pie was the absolute edge of the crust. We didn't knock down any points for it, but we wished it would've been a little crispier. There's one place in Neptune NJ we prefer the most, but this place is a close second. Not sure if we'd come back a third time as it's a 1.5 hour ride and the GSP....Boy....maybe because it was the holiday season and people were out driving and shopping...but for us, it was NOT an easy ride. Thank god the place had a bar, I needed a drink after getting there. . It was a solid pie, probably didn't need th